
MODULES:  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  |  7  |  8  |   9  |
| RESOURCES | TECH SUPPORT | INDEX |
MODULE 8
SUICIDE PREVENTION
The majority of the material in this module was provided by the Samaritans Suicide Prevention Center, Family and Children's Service of the Capital Region, Inc., Albany, NY
Need someone to talk to?
Samaritan Crisis Services provides a Crisis Helpline
689-4673 (HOPE)
as well as Direct Services to Suicide Survivors
|
The goal of this module is...
...to provide suicide statistics and risk factors specific to the GLBT Community, explain the global risk factors and warning signs for suicide, and teach you what you can do to help someone who might be suicidal.
PART ONE: The Greater Suicide Risk in the LGBT Communities.
In the New York Capital District almost TWO PEOPLE PER WEEK kill themselves. We don't have specific statistics to indicate the number who are Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual or Transgendered, but we know that those of us who are, are at higher risk. Studies consistently show that we are at a higher lifetime risk for suicidal ideation and at a higher risk for suicide attempts. The statistics are staggering. An estimated 30% of youth who die by suicide identify as G, L, B, T, or Q. While 12% of men in the general male population report having made a suicide plan, the number is 21.3% for Gay and Bisexual men. And wheras 2.3% of 'straight' men report a prior suicide attempt, the number of Gay and Bisexual men reporting an attempt is 11.9%. [Paul et al. (2002)]
The problem is especially troublesome among teens. In addition to the usual stressors associated with growing up, LGBT youth must deal with the added emotional distress of stigmatization, victimization, and antigay hostility.
The following are some of the related factors that place Gay and Bisexual men at special risk:
- Native American
- Men who do not identify as any particular sexual orientation
- Inadequate education
- Lower annual income
- Less than full-time employment
- Parents who had a drug or alcohol problems
- Experienced physical or sexual abuse as a child
- Younger at time of coming out
- Early repeated antigay harassment
- Recent first sexual experience with another man
- Recent disclosure of one's gay or bisexual identity to others
For GLBTQ Youth, there are added factors:
- Hopelessness (9x as likely report suicidality)
- Methamphetamine use (3.5 x as likely to report suicidality)
- Homelessness (4x as likely report suicidality)
- In-School Victimization (almost 3x as likely to report suicidality)
- Youth who are least likely to reveal their sexual orientation to anyone
- Males with more feminine gender characteristics
- Those who recognized same-sex sexual orientation at an earlier age
- Those who have been sexually abused
- Those who in the past year identified as GLBT
- Family Problems
Given these facts, it is important for you to be able to recognize when someone (even yourself) is at risk. The first step is to understand the issue and separate the Myths from the Facts.
- MYTH: People who talk about suicide are unlikely to commit suicide.
Talking about suicide is a warning. Of any ten person who complete an act of suicide, eight have given definite warnings of their suicidal intentions.
- MYTH: Teenage boys are the age group most likely to commit suicide.
The elderly are most at risk for committing suicide. Youth, ages 15-24 are in a high risk pool, but actually the elderly are at highest risk for suicide, as elderly adults have suicide rates close to 50% higher than all other age groups.
- MYTH: Males are most likely to be suicidal
Women think about suicide more often then men. In fact, women attempt suicide three times more often than men; however, Men complete suicide more often than women because they choose more lethal means of killing themselves (guns, hanging), whereas women are more likely to chose less lethal means (overdosing). The following chart illustrates the differences.
- MYTH: Suicide happens without warning
Most suicidal people give many clues and warning signs regarding their suicidal intention. These Warning Signs are actions and behaviors that are cause for immediately seeking professional help. The American Association of Suicidology reports the following examples of actions/behaviors that should cause you to seek professional help immediately.
- Someone threatening to hurt or kill him/herself, or talking of wanting to hurt or kill him/herself.
- Someone looking for ways to kill him/herself by seeking access to firearms, available pills or other means.
- Someone talking or writing about death, dying or suicide, when these actions are out of the ordinary for the person.
- Hopelessness
- Rage, uncontrolled anger, seeking revenge
- Acting recklessly or engaging in risky activities, seemingly without thinking
- Feeling trapped ' like there's no way out
- Increasing Alcohol or Drug Use
- Withdrawing from friends, family and society
- Anxiety, agitation, unable to sleep or sleeping all the time
- Dramatic Mood Changes
- No reason for living; no sense of purpose in life
- MYTH: Talking with someone about suicide may encourage them to complete suicide.
Actually, talking may provide relief from painful emotions. We may feel uncomfortable in asking the question, 'Are you thinking about suicide?', but if we do ask the question and the person is indeed suicidal, this will help them, as most people are relieved when someone recognizes their pain, and gives them a chance to talk about it. Research has proven that if they were not previously suicidal, asking them the question will not put the idea in their head. Asking someone about suicide may be one of the most important tools that you have (e.g. 'Are you feeling so down that you have thought about suicide?')
- MYTH: Suicidal people are fully intent on dying.
Most suicidal people are undecided about living or dying ' this is called suicidal ambivalence. A part of them wants to live, however, death seems like the only way out of their pain and suffering. They may allow themselves to 'gamble with death' , leaving it to others to save them. Wanting to kill themselves may have nothing to do with wanting to die and instead may have to do with wanting to escape the pain they are feeling. We can see differing levels of ambivalence by looking at the circumstances surrounding a suicide attempt or completion. For example:
- The man who told his girlfriend he was going downstairs to the bathroom, then went downstairs, left all the lights on, and hung himself. (She is in close proximity, chances are she will find him and save him, but the means he chose was highly lethal)
- The girl who took 8 sleeping pills (not medically serious attempt) and then told her best friend and her guidance counselor (not a very serious attempt, but definitely a serious cry for help ' indicating she is in pain)
- The man who never drank alcohol because it is against his religion, who went for a midnight walk in the woods in the middle of the winter, didn't tell anyone where he was going, and purposely drank enough alcohol that he passed out. He was very intent on killing himself.
- MYTH: Improvement following a suicide attempt or crisis usually means that the risk is over.
Most suicides occur within days or weeks of improvement, when the individual has the energy and motivation to actually follow through with his/her suicidal thoughts. Most people will see helping those with suicide ideation as a lost cause (i.e. Even if people do improve they will still kill themselves no mater what). What is needed is setting up professional help and creating future plans of actions for the suicidal.
- MYTH: Most suicides occur around the winter holidays ' in December.
More suicides occur during the Spring and early Summer months. Why?' Some say it's because of the contrast between the 'outside environment' and the 'inside environment' (the mind) of someone who may be feeling depressed and suicidal. For someone who is feeling depressed and/or suicidal, what's happening inside is in grave contrast to what's happening outside. Here's a chart illustrating the periods during the year when suicide is more likely.
PART TWO: Causes and Symptoms
Why do people consider and/or contemplate suicide? The reasons are complex and varied, but can be summarized as the need for relief from unbelievably painful mental, emotional or physical suffering. The person contemplating suicide just wants to remove him or her self from an incredibly painful situation. Suicide is not about wanting to die, but about a powerful need to end the pain. Suicidal people share feelings of hopelessness, helplessness, and isolation, a desire for a solution to their problems, and deep uncertainties about living and dying.
| The American Foundation for Suicide Prevention says that 90% of people who die by suicide are suffering from one or more psychiatric disorders. For example, people with Bipolar Disorder ar at an increased risk of suicide, even during manic episodes, because of a high level of impulsivity. 25% of all suicides are in individuals with alcohol use disorders. But lacking the research to separate out LGBT suicides from the general population we cannot say how many are suffering from a psychiatric disorder and how many are suffering from the "painful situation" produced by the ignorance and intolerance of a society that has not yet accepted us. |
Possible Causes
There are many aspects of life that can cause Emotional and Mental Stress:
| Death of a loved one
Divorce / separation
Imprisonment
Injury/illness ( self / family )
Marriage/ engagement
Loss of job
Retirement
Pregnancy
Sexual Problems |
Change in financial status
Change of job / work
Mortgage or loan
Foreclosure of mortgage/loan
Change in responsibilities
Moving house
Holidays
Christmas
Minor violations of the law
|
Very often, people need to talk about these all too common life stressors, but there's no one they feel they can talk to. This is why it's important for us to recognize when someone is feeling this need and be able to direct them to support services.
Symptoms
There are three critical risk factors for suicide: Desire, Capability, and Intent.
Suicidal Desire exists when one or more of the following is present:
- Suicidal Ideation: wanting to hurt oneself and/or others
- Psychological Pain
- Hopelessness
- Helplessness
- Perceived Burden on Others
- Feeling Trapped
Suicidal Capability exists when one or more of the following is present:
- A history of suicide attempts
- Exposure to someone else's death by suicide
- A history of or current violence to others
- The availability of the means for hurting oneself or others
- Being "high" or intoxicated
- Substance Abuse
- Acute symptoms of mental Illness
- A recent and dramatic mood change
- Being out of touch with reality
- Extreme agitation or rage
- An increase in anxiety
- Unable to sleep or sleeping all the time
- Recent acts and/or threats of aggression
Suicidal Intent exists when one or more of the following is present:
- An attempt is in progress
- There is a PLAN in place of how to hurt self or other
- There are Preparatory behaviors
- Organizing personal affairs
- Materials are being gathered that are needed to hurt oneself/others
- Rehearsing the act
- Expressing the intent to die
In addition to these, there are special risk factors for youth
- Parental psychopathology (depressive disorders, mood disorders)
- Family History of Suicidal Behavior
- Life Stressors such as Interpersonal Losses (relationship breakup, argument with parents)
- Legal and Disciplinary problems
- Physical and Sexual Abuse
- Conduct Disorders
- Sexual/Gender Orientation
- Juvenile Delinquency
- Contagion or Imitation (exposure to media accounts of suicidal behavior; exposure to suicidal behavior in friends and acquaintances)
- Living alone/Runaways
- Aggressive-impulsive behaviors
Imminent Warning Signs
Very often, a suicidal person will make remarks that clearly indicate their intent:
- 'I've decided to kill myself.'
- 'I wish I were dead.'
- 'I'm going to end it all.'
Sometimes, the remarks are not so blunt or obvious, but indicate a sucidial ideation.
- 'I'm tired of life, I just can't go on.'
- 'My family would be better off without me.'
- 'Who cares if I'm dead anyway.'
- 'I just want out.'
- 'Pretty soon you won't have to worry about me.'
If you see any of the following, take action immediately; immediately seek professional help:
- Someone is threatening to hurt or kill him/herself, or talking of wanting to hurt or kill him/herself.
- Someone is looking for ways to kill him/herself by seeking access to firearms, available pills, or other means.
- Someone is talking or writing about death, dying or suicide (when these actions are out of the ordinary for the person)
PART THREE: Prevention
There are a number of factors that can help to reduce the risk of suicide. Having a connection with a Health Care System and knowing where to find immediate support when needed. Support systems include family and community. We shouldn't wait for a crisis to occur to form a supportive community. It should already be in place and available. If community support isn't available, having a positive relationship with a 'helper' can provide the necessary support.
Recognizing that help is needed and already having strong coping skills are important, as is a sense of purpose. For some, having religious or ethical beliefs that prohibit suicide reduce the risk. Planning for the future and seeing hope in the future are also important.
And when there's the potentiality suicide, a built-in rescue plan set up in advance can provide the needed resources to head it off .
In addition to the above, an important ally for youth is the presence of a Gay-Straight Alliance [GLSEN] within the school.
How to deal with a Potential Suicide
LISTEN...let the person talk about it. We have the 'magic' to transform and heal ' to neutralize emotional pain. Consider what you would want if you were overwhelmed and in crisis: someone to listen to you; someone who really understands your feelings; someone who will not judge you or tell you what to do. These are the things you can provide. By providing these important things, in a matter of 20 minutes they can feel '200%' better.
If you are concerned about the seriousness of the person you're listening to, consider asking these Specific Suicide Risk Assessment Questions
- Are you thinking about suicide right now?
Asking about the present is important, but not the end of the assessment. Sometimes, the person will deny thinking about suicide now, because it is too difficult to talk about, or they are ashamed of it.
- Have you been thinking about suicide at all in the last few months?
Asking about the recent past is important, because it may be easier for the person to admit to intent in the past.
- Have you ever attempted suicide? And if so how, and what was your intent?
Asking about attempts is important because we know that previous suicide attempts are the single most important risk factor for future suicide completion. And asking about how is important because we want to know if it was a lethal attempt ' that the person was lucky to be discovered and saved ' or if it was a very non-lethal attempt ' this also may predict the method of future attempts. You also want to ask about intent because if the person wanted to die, but was saved this means the person is more at risk now than if the person wanted to affect change in another person.
- Do you have a plan?
- Do you have the means?
- Have you set a time?
If the person has thoughts about suicide, has made a plan, and has the means available, the time is imminent,
Do not leave him/her alone...Call 9-1-1
At this point, the suicidal person needs you to be accepting and non-judgmental. He or she should be taken seriously. You should be confident and positive in your comments. As soon as possible, you should begin to mobilize resources and seek professional help
 |
EXERCISE 24: Two Scenarios
|
Please read the following scenario (have a paper and pen or pencil handy)
You know of a young man; he's just 16 and he has repeatedly expressed the feeling that 'wants to die' and, 'no one can help me.' He has been referred many times by his school counselor for outpatient mental health treatment, but he never shows up for appointments. He tells you that he used to take medication, but 'my meds never helped me and I won't go back on them.' One day he says, "this is my last weekend, I won't be around on Sunday." And he says that he heard voices telling him to cut himself or cause a gas explosion, saying he plans to blow himself up and that, 'its going to be really messy.' When you ask how he would feel if someone else got hurt in the explosion, he says, 'I'll be dead, I don't care.'
Now...in a sentence or two, jot down your emotional reaction to this young man's behavior. When you finish read the next scenario.
A young woman you met recently appears to be a very sweet, yet very troubled young woman. She tells you that she wishes she could just 'go to sleep and never wake up.' When you ask if she's thinking of killing herself, she says, 'Yes, I just can't live with this pain anymore.' She tells you that she has a stash of pills in her bag and that she is planning to take them all in the next few days. She says she has already practiced by getting them out and counting them, placing them in front in a rehearsal for when she will complete her final act. You talk to her and she sits patiently and listens, but doesn't offer any indication that she has changed her mind.
Again, in a sentence or two, jot down your emotional reaction to this young woman's behavior, then read on.
Most often, people take the second case study more seriously and feel much more sympathetic toward her, whereas in the first case study, people often feel angry and are more dismissive of him. They often make remarks like 'he's just looking for attention.' But both of these individuals present very high risk situations. The point we're making is that your emotional reaction should not dictate the type of treatment or care that someone who is experiencing suicidal ideation gets. Regardless of the impact the person makes; no matter what their personality or what they may "seem" to be saying, they must be taken seriously.
Here are some numbers you can call as a helper looking for guidance in the moment, OR you can give to the person in crisis, for them to call and talk.
- National Suicide Prevention Lifeline 1-800-273- 8255 (TALK)
- Samaritans Helpline 689-4673 (HOPE), 11 am ' 11 pm
- The Trevor Project (GLBT Youth) 1-866-4U-TREVOR
- Albany County Mobile Crisis 447-9650
- Spanish Speaking Helpline 1-877-298-3373 (AYUDESE)
|