TOPIC INDEX
    Assumptions About Gender

    In many other cultures outside of the western medical tradition, a third gender is recognized which does not fit "male" or "female" medical definitions. Native American culture includes the Berdache, Indian culture recognizes the Hijra, and the Xanith recognize the Oman. In western culture, gender is assigned at birth based solely on external genitalia. The impact of this arbitrary gender assignment extends to every corner of our experience.

    Most of the time, gender assignment goes unquestioned, but for some, it causes extreme discomfort. We may be forced to express the gender we were assigned even if we don't identify with that gender. If this describes you, your medical and mental health provider needs to meet you "where you are," without any assumptions or forced roles. He or she should not identify you as belonging to either pole in the dimorphic gender system.

    Furthermore, the provider needs to know that there's some controversy regarding the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM's) diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorder (GID). Intersexed people are petitioning the medical establishment to stop surgically altering intersexed infants. If your caregiver wants to provide the most respectful, ethical care he or she needs to understand the newly emerging issues involved in treating gender variant people.

    If a provider interacts with you in an inappropriate or hurtful way, they need to be taught that choosing the most respectful language and ways of communicating are the proper alternatives. We need to make them aware that crossing gender lines as a means of expressing oneself is not something we take lightly; it takes a great deal of courage. We're confident, though, that once most professionals are aware of the challenges they will be better able to assess and assist us and our family members.

    We can begin educating our health care providers by explaining to them that gender is fluid. It is not fixed or rigidly defined, it is not always either male or female. This may be a totally new way of thinking for them. Giving them the definitions for sex, sexual identity, gender identity, gender role, sexual orientation, and intersexuality will help illustrate the fluidity of gender.

    A common way to view sexuality is as a continuum from "feminine" to "masculine" with most people falling somewhere along a line between the two extremes. But a more accurate view uses overlapping concentric circles to show the interrelationship of these elements.

    Notice the distinctions between biological sex, core gender identity, gender role expression, sexual orientation, and the ways that they overlap and impact one another For newcomers to the field of gender identity and expression these can be very confusing. They involve complex issues. Many professionals have not dealt with these, so it may be incumbent upon you to provide them with the necessary information to 'educate' them.

    See also:

    • The Role of Language
    • Definition of Sex
    • Definition of Gender Identity
    • Definition of Gender Roles
    • Definition of Sexual Orientation


      CLICK HERE FOR

      MORE RESOURCES
      ON THIS TOPIC


      The information provided by Rainbow Access Initiative, Inc. is for educational purposes only and is not intended to render medical advice or professional services. The information should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health problem or a disease and is not a substitute for professional care. If you have or suspect you may have a health problem, consult your healthcare provider.
      Rainbow Access Initiative is a 501(c)3 tax-exempt organization.
      These materials were produced through a grant from the New York State Department of Health.
      You may not use them without the written permission of Rainbow Access Initiative, Inc.
      Permission may be obtained by contacting the Director.